RareBeast wrote:
Lifebloom wins because each stack of the Lifebloom gets the 42.86% +heal. So if you have a 3 stack you are getting 128.58% of your +heal. This (as well as the whole trinketed LB lasting forever being nerfed soon) is what makes Lifebloom so powerful - combined with how very cheap it's mana cost is.
I have a confused followup based on some in-game testing I just did. The in-game results (and I swear I'm not high or lying) seem much better even than your calculation here. I'm no math guy, so can somebody can please correct my errant logic or math? I do not have a single talent that affects my +heal, not even nurturing instinct in the feral tree.
First I tested Healing Touch. I popped it on myself five times with and without my healing gear, and threw out a few drool-worthy crits. In my tanking gear it healed for an average of 2878, and in my +861 healing gear it healed for an average of 3743. That's a difference of 865...right at the 100% I expected because of its 3.5 second cast time. (Closer than I expected out of a 5-shot test, actually.)
Then I tested Lifebloom and the fun began.
In my tanking gear, with no +heal, Lifebloom did this: x1: 39 per tick + 600 bloom = 873 total healing
x2: 78 per tick + 600 bloom = 1146 total healing
x3: 117 per tick + 600 bloom = 1419 healing
In my healing gear, with +861 healing, Lifebloom did this: x1: 102 per tick + 969 bloom = 1683 total healing
x2: 206 per tick + 970 bloom = 2412 total healing
x3: 309 per tick + 970 bloom = 3133 total healing
Since Lifebloom x1 is instant cast, I thought one cast of it would only get 42.86% of my +861 healing bonus, or +369. Right?
But that's 42.86% of my healig bonus is what the
bloom alone benefited.
On top of that, the total of the ticks was higher by by 441, 896, and 1344 in stacks of 1, 2, and 3 respectively.
So all told the spell x1 is getting +810, which is virtually ALL (94%) of my +healing bonus. x2 it's getting +1266, or 147%, and x3 it's getting +1714, which is 200% of my healing bonus. Is it just me or is this not even awesomer than what you said.
Our other instant cast, Rejuvenation, ticked for 265 x 4 = 1060 naked, and 454 x 4 = 1816 in my healing gear. That's a difference of 756, or 88% of my bonus.
So in a good but suspicious and potentially happy way, I have to say "WTF?!?"
Edited, Jan 7th 2008 10:54pm by JeeBar