Forum Settings
       
Reply To Thread

gear questionFollow

#1 Jan 02 2008 at 11:41 PM Rating: Decent
So I'm working off of athien's guide to get myself geared for kara and just had a few quick questions.

I got this on my first botanica run http://wow.allakhazam.com/search.html?q=beast+lord+cuirass (beastlord cuirass) but I've already got http://www.wowarmory.com/item-info.xml?i=28057 Bonechewer Berserker's Vest so which would be better? I doubt if I'll really spend a ton of time getting the full beastlord set, just due to the extremely crappy drop rate of the other pieces. I know that I'll lose 32 AP by switching, but was thinking that I could just make up for that in gems, and yes I know that I do get better stats with the beast lord.

then these http://wow.allakhazam.com/db/item.html?source=live;witem=28170 Auchenai Bracers over http://www.wowarmory.com/item-info.xml?i=24451 Lykul Bloodbands. Now with the bracers I'd lose +18 agility and + 18 stamina and only get +15 intellect and and extra +6 to my AP but the only nice thing is the MP/5


then these http://wow.allakhazam.com/db/item.html?source=live;witem=27528 Gauntlets of Desolation over these http://www.wowarmory.com/item-info.xml?i=25716 Handguards of Precision. With the gauntlets I lose +3 stamina, +20 agility and +6 AP, kind of not thinking it's worth it?


Oh and finally, sorry for the long post, I'm a BM spec and don't plan on respecing to SV to raid since guild already has a well geared SV hunter. Thx for any input
#2 Jan 03 2008 at 12:36 AM Rating: Good
So lets compare and start with the most easy one:

Gauntlets of Desolation: 32ap; 17crit rating; 2red sockets (assuming 2x8agi) = 48ap, 25crit rating = 1.25%crit; 48ap
Handguards of Precision: 20agi; 38ap = 0.5%crit; 58ap
By trading 0.75%crit for only 10ap Gauntlets of Desolation are the clearly better item.

Next two:
Beast Lord Cuirass: 30agi, 40ap, 4mp5, 24int, 2red, 1blue (socket with 2x8agi and 1x4agi/6sta for the socket bonus -> 24agi from gems and socket bonus) = 54agi, 40ap, 4mp5, 24int = 1.35%crit, 94ap, 4mp5, 24int
Bonechewer Berserker's Vest: 14agi, 72ap, 4mp5, 13int = 0.35%crit, 86ap, 4mp5, 13int.
Here the Beast Lord Cuirass is a ton better. You get 1% of extra crit, 8ap, 11int and don't loose anything...

And the next...
Auchenai Bracers: 36ap, 4mp5, 15int, 1red (assuming 1x8agi) = 0.2%crit, 44ap, 5mp5, 15int.
Lykul Bloodbands: 18agi, 30ap = 0.45%crit, 48ap
This one is really close. It is deciding whether to get 0.25%crit and 4ap over 5mp5 and 15int. If you can sustain your damage through boss fights I'd take the Lykul Bloodbands, if you constantly have mana issues go for the Auchenai Bracers.
Although you might just want to buy some PvP bracers as those have really solid stats:
Vindicator's Chain Bracers 23agi, 11crit rating, 24ap, 13int, 1yellow (assuming a 8crit rating gem) = 30.5crit rating, 47ap, 13int = 1.5%crit, 47ap, 13int.

The thing which you seem to have problems with when comparing items are those nice sockets. Don't underestimate their value.
Another thing which helps when comparing items is to know how to converse those values.
1agi = 0.5crit rating + 1ap
41agi or 20.5crit rating = 1%crit
#3 Jan 05 2008 at 8:59 AM Rating: Decent
******
27,272 posts
Íf you dont care to do pvp, Fekstalker Bracers are pretty solid and cheap as hell.
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 98 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (98)