shadedpole wrote:
What do you guys think I should do?
Well, I can tell you how things run in my guild, and then you can make your decision.
We currently have 6 warriors, and 2 feral druids. Of the warriors, 4 are spec'd prot, 2 are spec'd fury. All of them are expected to be capable tanks, and those who are dps spec'd are required to respec prot when a raid depends on it, which is a rare occurrence.
Now who gets that spot? Simple, the people who put in the time, and have the interest in it, are the ones that get to choose their spot. Currently our 2 DPS warriors are the ones that have been in the guild the longest, and both have spent a significant amount of time tanking. You put in the effort, you get the reward.
What I think you should do is simple. Tell them you will respec prot when needed for the raid, and be DPS spec when not. If they have problems with that, then you know to get out. However, I don't think it's unreasonable for them to ask you to be the proper spec to fill a certain role in a raid.