Forum Settings
       
« Previous 1 2 3
Reply To Thread

Is tailoring a MUST have?Follow

#1 Nov 30 2007 at 11:27 AM Rating: Default
*
78 posts
I have a lvl 40 something lock and curently doing mining/engineering. I was wonderinf how musy the shadow weave set at lvl 70 is really worth for end game. I am not planning to do a lot of PVPing and plan on doing some raiding. Will I get better gear from the instances then what I can tailor or will I need the set in order to do end game raid/instances?
#3 Nov 30 2007 at 1:23 PM Rating: Decent
***
1,729 posts
The FSW set does help for Kara, but if you can manage to get the Oblivian Rainment set you can make do with that. The Mana-Etched Regalia is good too. Both are will get you Kara ready w/o the FSW set. They are kinda difficult to obtain though, that's why a lot of 'lock just go for the FSW set.
#4 Nov 30 2007 at 2:16 PM Rating: Decent
**
821 posts
the fsw set is kickass! as well as the bop-tailoring boots which drop in ssc.
you can earn a shedload of money with tailoring as well.

Edited, Nov 30th 2007 5:17pm by Oakenwrath
#5 Dec 01 2007 at 7:33 PM Rating: Default
*
95 posts
Quote:
the fsw set is kickass! as well as the bop-tailoring boots which drop in ssc.



FSW is great for pre-raiding. Thats about it, once you get to the point where you can start collecting T4 pieces FSW loses its perks quite fast.

The majority of really good tailoring items for warlocks are BoE, able to be gotten without having tailoring yourself(Spellstrike set, Girdle of Ruination, Belt of Blasting). The few good tailoring items that are BoP, such as the Boots of Blasting have equivilent items which are just as good if not better that drop off of raid bosses(using the Boots of Blasting as an example, the Boots of Shifting Nightmare that drop off Hydross are just as good if not better).



Quote:
you can earn a shedload of money with tailoring as well.


Since when? The only real money makers from tailoring is the BoE patterns, most of which ppl will come to you with their own mats and only give you money for a nether/tip. The only other thing is the 20 slot bags, which have a horrendous mat cost and require you to try and sell for 200-300g just to make a SMALL profit off of, and most ppl refuse to pay 200-300g for a single 20 slot bag when they can pay 10-20g for an 18 slot. If your looking to make money off a profession I would suggest something like Herbalism instead, Tailoring have been proven time and again to nothing but a huge money sink when it comes to the topic of profit.


That being said. I would suggest picking up tailoring if you dont ever plan on raiding past Kara. This set is great if you only ever do 5 mans and Kara. Once you start doing 25 mans though the set basically becomes garbage.
#6 Dec 01 2007 at 11:33 PM Rating: Decent
**
821 posts
Quote:
Once you start doing 25 mans though the set basically becomes garbage.

once you start...of course if you got a guild farming kara, gruul and ssc the set ain´t that good(on a sidenote: i waited for my t4 shoulders to drop for 15 weeks!!! i got my t5 shoulders instead..now t4 warlock drops everytime we do gruul..), but if you start raiding doing the gruul kara the set is certainly kick-***...so fu to whoever rated me down.


Quote:
Since when? The only real money makers from tailoring is the BoE patterns



bullsh*t. sell the aldor or scryer threads will make you rich within no time, if you farm for the primals. And of course the BoE-patterns are really nice as well. Primal Nether drops in every heroic instance and you´ll be running quiet a few, just chose greed and sell it. Loads of money on the fly...so fu again to whomever rated me down.

Edited, Dec 2nd 2007 2:33am by Oakenwrath
#7 Dec 02 2007 at 6:08 AM Rating: Decent
***
2,754 posts
no
#8 Dec 02 2007 at 6:43 AM Rating: Good
**
821 posts
elite answer jenova.
#9 Dec 02 2007 at 7:02 AM Rating: Decent
***
2,754 posts
indeed. to elaborate. no craft is a must for any class or spec. in the end there's 99% of the time going to be better gear than the crafted stuff in the long run
#10 Dec 02 2007 at 11:57 AM Rating: Default
*
95 posts
Quote:
bullsh*t. sell the aldor or scryer threads will make you rich within no time, if you farm for the primals. And of course the BoE-patterns are really nice as well. Primal Nether drops in every heroic instance and you´ll be running quiet a few, just chose greed and sell it. Loads of money on the fly...so fu again to whomever rated me down.



Again, much like the BoE paterns, most people will bring the mats to you. Meaning your only gonna get paid for the Nether/tip. Imo 75g(going rate on my server) for a Nether plus a tip isnt worth mass farming Nethers to sell. This is all of course not counting the fact that most established guilds are going to have tailors already who are willing to part with Nethers for free in order to help gear up fellow guildies. In general most of the crafting professions(Tailoring, LW, BS, Eng) are notoriously horrable for trying to make money. Considering the ammount of money you have to sink into the profession to max it as well as the fact that most people dont buy BoE items mats and all. The majority of people provide their own mats and only pay for Nethers and provide a tip. Gathering professions are the real money makers, with Alchemy and Enchanting coming in after those, but again, most established guilds are going to have members who are able to make Flasks/Pots and do Enchants free of charge if you provide the mats, so even these arent the best money makers.

Wtf is up with people rating you down Oaken, I swear every thread you post on you get rated down for no reason. Makes you wonder if theres not someone just out to ***** with ya.
#11 Dec 02 2007 at 12:00 PM Rating: Good
***
2,754 posts
curious Q. how do even tell if someone has rated you up or down?
#12 Dec 02 2007 at 1:11 PM Rating: Decent
**
821 posts
because my karma often goes from decent when i make the post down to default, thats how i/one can tell.

about them professions you are right, as soon as you got an established guild you can get almost everything available ingame at only the material costs. on our server though you get around 90g for primal nether and you can sell the threads for quiet a coinat least on our server.
i chose alchy/herbalism myself and mana/healpot stack goes for around 9g which is really little i think...then again i can sell a stack of Nighmare Vine for around 36g.

Edited, Dec 2nd 2007 4:12pm by Oakenwrath
#13 Dec 02 2007 at 3:27 PM Rating: Decent
*
95 posts
Just goes to show you the difference of enconomies server to server. A stack of mana/health pots usually go for around 16g on my server.

Herbalism/Enchanting myself. I can do all my own enchants, and farm all the mats for my pots/flasks myself and just have guildies make them for me. I happen to love this setup as if I really need money I can just sell herbs(which imo is the best money maker in the game) and along with having Cooking and Enchanting and Fishing I can farm all the mats for my raiding consumables myself. Meaning I never have to waste any of my gold on the consumables I use on a daily basis(sta food, spell dmg food, spell crit food, wizard oil, flasks of pure death, healing and rejuv pots, and destruction pots). Atm all I use gold on are repairs, gems, and alts.

Btw, I hadnt got to say it yet, but Solarian down on our first night of attempts(Nov 26th). Just got Vashj and Kael now till were in Hyjal. All of Kara cleared, all of Gruuls cleared, Magtheridon dead, 5/6 SSC, 3/4 TK, and 3/6 ZA(we havent put much effort into clearing ZA, we only run it on off raiding nights). Not too bad considering we only started raiding as a guild September 28th.

On an off note, they REALLY must have nerfed Solarian when they nerfed her a couple of patches ago, cuz omg she was easy, I personally think shes easier than Loot Reaver.....er um...Void Reaver, which is saying ALOT.
#14 Dec 02 2007 at 4:05 PM Rating: Good
***
2,029 posts
I have yet to make any money on tailoring. It's a loss compared to selling the cloth on the AH, or even making bandages and selling them. Tailoring is NOT a money profession. Unless your game economy is far different than every other server's I've seen, farming the mats for an item and selling them nets you a fair amount more cash than selling the crafted item itself.

No profession is required for any class, except maybe priests, and especially shadow priests. The PMC and FSW set for them is borderlining on overpowered - no clear upgrades from FSW shoulders till Anetheron, robes till Illidan, and boots... well, never.

For warlocks, you can expect to replace the FSW shoulders with T4 or T5 (if you need the hit rating), robes with T4 (for hit rating) or Hateful Echoes off Hydross (as destro but don't need the hit), and the boots from Hydross or the BoP boot pattern (which requires tailoring anywho). The frozen shadoweave stuff will certainly last you a while, unless you jump straight into a Tier-5-level guild (which is unlikely). Also, Blizz has stated that they intend to do the same with with the next expansion as with BC; that is, offer very powerful tailoring sets that far outclass anything until the first tiered gear and possibly last even longer. I'd pick it up.
#15 Dec 02 2007 at 5:09 PM Rating: Excellent
***
2,754 posts
isfreak. as destro you DO need the hit. even more so than afliction due to having no talented hit. heck +hit is the best stat for destruction warlocks.
also. every spec needs the hit, and if you're in fsw gear, you're VERY unlikely to be at the hit cap (202) in which case you can always upgrade the gear with more hit stuff (as afliction this means less talents wasted in suppression and used on damage/helping raid. as dest it means you can actually spec dest and deal decent damage)

you can, and should, replace all of FSW with T4. it's better 100% of the time for bosses, and probably equal to FSW for trash mobs. remember. as a lock (regardless of spec)
+spell hit (till 202 hit) > +spell haste > +spell damage (shadow > fire, +damage > both imo) > +spell crit
#16 Dec 02 2007 at 6:52 PM Rating: Decent
***
3,761 posts
Quote:
I have yet to make any money on tailoring. It's a loss compared to selling the cloth on the AH, or even making bandages and selling them. Tailoring is NOT a money profession. Unless your game economy is far different than every other server's I've seen, farming the mats for an item and selling them nets you a fair amount more cash than selling the crafted item itself.


Not sure where you play, but netherweave bags are profitable on every server I've ever seen. Cloth sells for 3g/stack, netherweave bags need 24 cloth (3.6g) and a 40s rune thread (40s). So 4g to make the bag, and I sell them for 6.5-9g a piece depending on the day. I can farm huge amounts of cloth as a warlock while grinding for other stuff (arcane tomes mostly) and come out with tons of bags,

Normal netherweave bags are about the only profitable thing I've found in tailoring though. I still like my tailoring/enchanting setup on my lock though, I always make more gold grinding then I would gathering (200-260g/hour). Disenchant 90% of green/blue drops unless they're worth seriously more gold then their disenchanted counterparts would be worth.

I've seen alot of locks in black temple who are still wearing crafted pieces like boots of blasting, or FSW robe. Maybe the piece you're after doesn't drop for you, I've killed mag plenty of times and never seen my T4 robe drop. I passed on T4 helm because I like my spellstrike helm better. We bring a ton of mages/warlocks to our raids along with 2 shadow priests, thats just our guild makeup. The odds of me getting pieces to drop are fairly low, so I'm glad I'm still topping meters in lots of crafted stuff in the low/mid-T5 range even with poor luck on drops.

Is it necessary? No, but if you think tailoring is worthless after kara you're an idiot.

Edited, Dec 2nd 2007 9:56pm by mikelolol
#17 Dec 02 2007 at 8:46 PM Rating: Decent
***
2,754 posts
boots of blasting are good. but if you#re already at the hit cap before them then the spell haste boots from ZA are better. the belt of blasting is amazing and arguably the 2nd best belt in the game, but it's BoE so anyone can have it. also if you're unlucky enough to never get the gear you're after then poor you, but you can't compare the fsw stuff (and 90% of all other crafted epics) to the dropped stuff as there really isn't any comparison. they're just simply there for the less hardcore players / very unlucky ones.
#18 Dec 02 2007 at 9:49 PM Rating: Decent
I leveled tailoring spending way too much gold to get the FSW set and the replaced it 2 or 3 Kara runs later. I then switched to picking herbs which saves me a ton of gold and makes me a little. Really wish i would have started with herbing but FSW looks so purty at level 10.
#19 Dec 03 2007 at 1:29 AM Rating: Good
***
1,571 posts
Some of us dont raid for whatever reason.
I couldnt have found better gear in normal instances, getting FSW was really a small cost compared to everything I spent gold on in past few months.
Just to mention 2 epic flying mounts for my both toons, FSW is marginal and serves me really well.

#20 Dec 03 2007 at 1:49 AM Rating: Good
Quite right, Sethy. FSW is worth the investment in tailoring. Once you have it, switch for a money maker if you wish.

I'm just PvP-ing now with my 70, while levelling a warrior alt, with the aim of getting the full Gladiator Dreadweave. For me, that's better than the FSW set (for an Aff 'lock) - but if I'm wrong, someone please tell me.
#21 Dec 03 2007 at 2:09 AM Rating: Good
***
3,761 posts
Quote:
I leveled tailoring spending way too much gold to get the FSW set and the replaced it 2 or 3 Kara runs later. I then switched to picking herbs which saves me a ton of gold and makes me a little. Really wish i would have started with herbing but FSW looks so purty at level 10


What did you replace it with? That robe from kara is terrible compared to FSW, so are those boots. The T4 shoulders don't drop until high king in gruuls, and the robe doesn't drop until mag. Think you were a little preemptive on dropping tailoring, just becaues its purple doesn't mean its better...

Quote:
Quite right, Sethy. FSW is worth the investment in tailoring. Once you have it, switch for a money maker if you wish.

I'm just PvP-ing now with my 70, while levelling a warrior alt, with the aim of getting the full Gladiator Dreadweave. For me, that's better than the FSW set (for an Aff 'lock) - but if I'm wrong, someone please tell me.


If you're just doing arena, no reason to go tailoring. You don't even need it to raid, I never said you did. The set can last you a very long time though. Most guilds only do Mag a handful of times, I mean is he really worth farming for T4 when you can be working on T5 content? Most guilds dont seem to think so. I'd replace FSW robe with T4, but its still a close call and you can definately live without it.

Next up is robes of Hydross, if you get them, great, those are the ones you're most likely to wear into T6 content, but of course some caster heavy raids won't be able to equip every caster in those robes (~10% drop chance, how many times will you farm Hydross before you hit MH + BT? 15? 20? You might equip 2 casters in your guild with those).

After that are vestments off Vashj and T5 off kael, I know alot of guilds just down these so they can GTFO of T5 and start farming the first few bosses in MH/BT. Its almost like a reward for finally clearing the T5 content, you get a huge amount of bosses who are much easier to most guilds to farm that open up once you get into T6 content, almost nobody goes back through SSC/TK once they can raid T6 stuff.


So IMO, an entire average guild progressing through end-game might see 1 T4 robe, 2-3 robes off Hydross, and maybe 1-2 robes off Kael/Vashj combined (remember tier tokens are shared with hunters + mages).

Edited, Dec 3rd 2007 5:18am by mikelolol
#22 Dec 03 2007 at 3:40 AM Rating: Decent
All fair points, mike, but I don't raid...hence, the PvP gear to replace FSW - am I right, is the question?
#23 Dec 03 2007 at 3:59 AM Rating: Decent
***
1,571 posts
As far as money making goes, I dont think I lost that much on any of my professions and I am having steady income right now.

Tailoring I use to get arcane dust, I have level 20 enchanting alt I DE the belts on, I am never out of dust and essences for whatever enchant I need plus nice amount of extras for sale.

Alchemy I use to make earthstorm diamonds, I fish for water, I buy earth, I get green gems from prospecting on my hunter - every gem I make nets me around 60-70g each day.
I gather herbs on hunter too and make all the potions I need for my 2 70ies, some for guild bank and some for sale. But I just raised herbalism on her recently, I used to buy herbs in AH and could still afford to use any potion I could think of.

With JC on hunter I prospect. I buy ore for 40g 2 stacks max, out of that I get 2-3 gems that sell around 50g each when I cut them.

I never actually tried engineering or BS but I am sure if I set my mind on it I would find some way to make a profit out of them too.

It certainly depends on server economy but I dont think prices compared vary that much. If lets say cut gems go for less then probably the ore goes for less too.

Edited, Dec 3rd 2007 7:01am by Sethy
#24 Dec 03 2007 at 5:17 AM Rating: Decent
Gems (cut) are typically 40-50g on my server. Meta gems, however, more like 200g. Which I think is taking the ****, frankly.
#25 Dec 03 2007 at 5:52 AM Rating: Decent
***
1,571 posts
Hehehe I wish... around 90-100 on mine.
I guess it depends which one too.
It takes me 6g for primal earth to make and cut a meta gem on my 2 toons. I dont have some designs yet though and I hate to predict which one will sell that day or have no competition so I rather sell uncut ones for little less.

But 194g would be a pretty nice pocket money every day :D

#26 Dec 03 2007 at 9:44 AM Rating: Decent
***
2,029 posts
Quote:
isfreak. as destro you DO need the hit. even more so than afliction due to having no talented hit. heck +hit is the best stat for destruction warlocks.
also. every spec needs the hit, and if you're in fsw gear, you're VERY unlikely to be at the hit cap (202)

I never said certain specs didn't need hit, only certain players (if you're hit capped via other gear). I'm really an *** to locks who think that Suppression means they only need 76 hit rating, and yes, T4 is an upgrade for chest and shoulders if you need the hit rating (which is likely). However, you may not - there was a lock in my guild (stubborn Malediction/Ruin :P) who was (buffed and talents) 20%crit, 202 hit rating, and 1200-ish damage with no T4. He got T4 for the 2-piece bonus, and so that he could regem a few hit gems back to +9dmg.

Edited, Dec 3rd 2007 11:44am by lsfreak
« Previous 1 2 3
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 114 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (114)