Looked over the stickies and didn't really see the answers to my specific questions.
A bit of a preface: my talents are specced 41 in Beastmaster, 18 in Marksman. I'm level 68. I am built to give good dps but also good soloing.
Right now I am using a green polearm I got from a Sporeggar quest.
Survivalist's Pike
+21 agility
+30 stam
+20 intellect
+40 attack power
I just got Terokk's Quill last night.
+54 agility
+33 stamina
I'm not sure which to use. The way I see it:
Survivalist's Pike gives me +7 more attack power, but a substantially smaller chance to crit. It also gives me 3 less stamina, which is of no consequence. +20 intellect on the Pike is nice, as it helps me grind longer.
Now, as I spend my time largely divided between instance runs, I can see bonuses to both. Terokk's seems to be worse for soloing as more crits = harder for pet to hold aggro and more int = longer grinding sessions. So, would it be best to use Survivalist's for soloing, Terokk's for grouping, or am I totally wrong on how to gear a hunter?
Also, which is better for a BM hunter, +35 agility to 2-handed weapon or Savagery? Does this depend on how much attack power / crit chance I currently have?