Am I wrongFollow

IMHO.... Yes you where wrong.

While the belt was something he could use, but would have been better fit for you I dont really think he was wrong for the belt roll.

As for the legs, him getting and upgrade is better than you get vendor trash, sorry.

This is why i havnt run a PUG in over 2 years.

Yeah but when a guy rolls need on every drop that we both can use. With no thought of the other class in the group until something drop that he really want. Yes I may have been wrong but a fare exchange is no robbery.

Fair exchange?

What were the Leggings that 'would have been a upgrade for him'? Did they have Int, spell damage, etc on it?

Rolling Need means it's a upgrade. You have the same chance that the other guy who Needs that item has on winning it. It was a upgrade for both of you.

Are you trying to tell us that this is the 1st time you've ran by this kind of thing in your 58'ish levels??

I won 2 plate items in one run once. Yes I was the only plate wearer, but even so, if there was another, if it's a upgrade I'm going to roll need on it. Leggings that are useless to you, Needing on them makes you like like a spoiled brat throwing a temper tantrum. Him winning the roll on the DPS item just makes him look like he's trying to max his gear sets out.

OP... It happens. You would think at lv 58+ you'd have picked up on that. In PUGs they're not running that with you for the 'grand ol' experience, and meeting new friends', sometimes that happens tho, you meet cool people. However, 90% of the time you're just out to get <better item here> or rep.

You asked for our opinions then you're going to try to argue your point further? When you are so far in the wrong it's not even funny.

Honestly, that plate belt isn't for a paladin who's main role is healing. I dont care who you are, a holy paly who is healing at lvl 60 can find a way better belt than ninja'ing that one from a warrior. Sure he might need a DPS set, but still, the sockets and stats are all wrong for a retardadin.

Meh, I understand that it's plate, but seriously, its more of a warrior item. If I were in your shoes, and it really upset me that much, I just would have left the group high and dry. Although its not any better than what you did. It would have given me another chance to get the Tenacious D with a different group.

Next time, if you are compiling your group, just get a different healer that can't wear plate. That simple. Just remember not to ninja anyone elses loot that you can't really use. If I can't use it, and its BoP or blue, I usually pass on the item and hope someone can DE (if no one needs it) and roll for the shard.

But seriously...you were wrong, i'm sure you're tired of hearing it, but you asked.

The only time someone should be allowed to roll need on an item they CAN use but aren't going to use straight away is if noone else is going to roll need on them.

Vengeance was yours!
My priesty almost lost the healing gloves from BF to a mage >.>

I'd have to say that you were in the wrong. He needed on an item that he actually can use, while you needed on one that has no benefit to you. He may be holy right now, but it's quite possible that he'd been holy for a while and wanted a change but simply didn't have the gear to make that change, and thus rolled on it.

However, while he's gearing up to respec he still needs to gear out his current spec, and so he'd need the other item, too. All you really did is make yourself seem immature loot-***** which kills your reputation.

You were out of order by rolling on the pally legs. You get yours in Zangarmarsh or Blood Furnace. Share and Share alike: There is appropriate gear for you coming up, so don't ninja (You Vendored it) from other classes. That is the ultimate WoW no-no. You will find yourself without a group and your name and reputation ruined.

Besides: There's a nice Blue Helmet in one of the Auchindoun helmets that is apparently designed for a Pally (it has +2 Mana), but is ideal for a warrior. You can legitimately Need for a Pally Helm.