Quote:
1. He DWs the same to axes which is a No-No as your off-hand should be faster, but they are also 2.4 and not slower than 2.6
Eh... under no circumstances should the off-hand be faster, the same speed or slower is what you are aiming for. Two of the same axe is fine and Axe of the Legion is a great one. He's spot on there.
Quote:
2. He is "suicide" build but never does pvp which i have also heard among enh shammys on the shaman forums is a No-No
It's certainly not ideal, enh/resto would give him far more survivability in a PvE setting, not such a big deal while leveling but if he wants to raid he will NEED to spec into resto for the 3% to hit.
Quote:
3. He pulls with lightning spells
Yup, so do I. Particularly if I need to separate one mob from a nearby group. I will often pull with LB so I have time to place my totems and also so that I can choose terrain that suits my style (I like to jump around a lot when I'm grinding... I know it's not the case but it feels like I crit more when I jump around hehe).
Quote:
4. He has quite a bit of intellect and +spell crit gear
This is where he will really be suffering, trying to mix up your gear like this just gimps you DPS. He needs to decide which spec he wants to be and start gearing specifically.
It's actually a fairly common misconception (scary how common) that mixing stats will up your DPS, it just won't, sure your spells will do more damage, but what you lose in melee damage means you end up with lower dps overall.
Quote:
here is his build
http://www.worldofwarcraft.com/info/class...00000000000
Not horrible, I don't personally like anticipation but it's not a bad talent. The one big problem with his build is Elemental Devastation. It's the reason he's taking spell crit I suspect and therein lies the problem. ED is a trick talent, the problem is that to get regular procs you need a fair amount of spell crit, to get that you are sacrificing melee stat. If he geared for pure melee he'd probably be running about 6%+ more crit than he is now and that's constant stat, not proc based. If he insists on Enh/Elem he should sink those 3 points in EotS on the same tier. That survivability will be far more valuable.