This post might seem pretty useless, but I just gotta write it somewhere :D..
I have played wow for 1½ year now, and only played on my hunter. I've seen allmost every raid instance (not BT yet), gotten my epic netherdrake mount etc etc. I have allways been a "hunter"-man, and never played anything else but him (avrage 5 - 7 hours a day for, well 1½ years :P) - and then came along the paladin alt.
From the first hour of playing my paladin I saw that he was some how a uniqe class. He could heal, do some crazy burstdmg (for pvp'ing), but the thing that Shined the most - AOE leveling and tanking.
He is now lvl 55, and he is taking all my wow time from my hunter (consideret retired).
I had a trip into brd last night, a full clear. My group was a bit sceptic (spelling :|) about bringing a tankadin, but off for some instance fun we went.
The group setup was: Healadin (lvl 56), 2xmages(both lvl 57), 1x warlock (lvl 58) and me as tankadin (lvl 55).
I told them to go for my target slowly until it was down to 70% or so, and then just run in and AOE and dot everything up.
Result = the fastest run i brd I've ever been doing (and even that I was underlevel, I had no problems holding aggro). We pulled 2 groups each time (where possible), and nuked them down faster then a group with a warrior tank (og drood) could kill one group (after what I have experienced with my hunter)
WALL OF TEXT CRITTS YOU FOR 10000000 dmg
Just the sec the Emperor drow (again, is that a word) his last breath I was spammed with: "Omg that was the smoothest run ever[...]", and so on. . . (padding myself on the shoulder now :-P).
So I hope I convinced atleast 4 wow'ers, that a paladin tank is just as good as any other tank (yes he is maybe abit twinket, yes my pala has several armor sets for both singel target tanking and trash/boss's with adds tanking).
It all comes down to: I love my paladin as tank - why would anyone NOT play tankadin.
Edited for spelling/gra (can't help it, I'm from Denmark :P)
Edited, Nov 9th 2007 10:56am by ashbazg