Contest: The Worst Armory Profile EVAR (Part II)Follow

I actually was looking at rep first, which is what really caught my eye. I guess thats what I was trying to build a case around.

Edit: Have you seen my gear?

Edited, Oct 30th 2007 5:59pm by ArundelvalEstar

I find it odd that the only blue gems you have(minus your meta) are the ones in your Blue BOE boots.

I would honestly have a **** fit if one of my rogues showed up to raid without blue gems and/or enchanted gear.

No nethercobra leg armor on a tier piece?
No +6 stats to chest?
+5 agi on your hands?
+3agi on your boots?
+2 weapon damage on BOTH weapons? Seriously man, Fiery will give you more DPS than that.

If your guild doesn't provide enchants, then you need to:
a)run instances and save the green drops to D/E
b)go buy mats off the AH and have someone do it for you

I just picked up my cloak last night, and didn't even put it on until I had +12agi on it.

This was Tyr's point. I wasn't trying to be a @#%^, just pointing out that you're not the only person in that position.

The thing is, this thread isn't about who is lacking a little bit in each department, but just completely fails at being a rogue.



Edit:sp

Edited, Oct 31st 2007 4:08pm by Salwrathis

Oh ! You are so damn elite ! You never hit 70 and you never run kara because of your uber skills, right ? You went right to Black Temple with your 70 quest gear, right.

You have no clue how long this guy is 70 and seriously, enough said.

Go die, but in a horrible hurting way.

Days at 70 really means nothing either if the person is a casual player who doesn't raid much. If the guy has appropriate Rogue gear that fits well with his talent spec and doesn't have too many pieces of gear 5+ levels lower than him then I don't see anything wrong as long as the guy is trying to get into groups appropriate to his gear level.

For the love of Bob, we just finished discussing why slightly sub-par gear isn't an indication of a bad rogue.

L2Read.

I'll bet you took a look at a few of the profiles linked here and said to yourself, "Self, you've got almost the same talent spec, and the armor isn't too far off either. Maybe I suck. Naw, I don't suck, these guys are just big cyber-jerks. Yeah, I'll rate them down and let them know what big meanie-heads they are."

This thread is about two things, really:

1. It's fun for the long-time posters who are constantly telling people what's wrong with their toons, and for new posters who want to delve in to this forum. We each post some profiles, look them over, and laugh to each other about how utterly horrible they are. "Wow, did you see this guy? 1.3 dagger in his MH, and he's got Hemo!"
b. It helps people learn how to play the class better. Instead of telling them how to do it (and we do so. Extensively), we show them, by example, how not to do it. Wearing druid gear and socketing your armor with STR gems? Post it here and allow everybody to comment.

You don't have to like it, and you don't have to participate in it. Besides, if you took my advice and learned to read, you'd have noticed that I was defending the profile that you posted, not flaming you for it.

Grow up, Sally.

My rogue is barely 53 and I can't wait to get to 70 and start raiding. I'm fairly new to the game (started not even 4 months ago) and my Rogue is my first character. The level grind to 70 doesn't offer much in the ways of learning to play your class in a group, but I jump in on instances when the chance arises. Looking forward to raiding, I understand that there are certain standards I have to meet. So while yes, this concept IS the ultimate flame thread, it helps new rogues like me to understand our group role in raids.

So yes, I would agree that this is an educational endeavor. After all, when I hit 70 and start raiding, I would rather know how to be the best damn rogue I can be than to just rush in without the slightest clue.

Oh, I just thought of something. Demea, what happens if someone put your profile up? Would you get pissed?

I miss being able to see actual Karma values =(.

Come on, we have a competition to get on with. So far I havent seen near the awfulness of last rounds rogues. Ill try to contribute but I dont really know where to start, do you guys just go down the list on the armory or is there more method to your madness?

Boo.

Edited, Nov 1st 2007 9:38pm by Pinkbullet

I wasnt attacking YOU demea, i was attacking the entire thread, but thanks for pwning me anyways.