Quote:
Truth is not found beneath math, math is a function of logical truth. Math is a tangible function of music which is the universal language of humanity. Therefore music, which contains the sub realms of math, creativity, and imagery is the only truth that will outlast humanity.
Funny, this quote is not logically sound. Mr. Spok would SO rip this apart.
You need proof that math is "the" universal language of humanity - not only that it is a universal language (some people hate Beethoven, e.g.), but also that it is "the" u.l., implying strongly that it's the ONLY u.l. of h. Maybe it isn't. Art tends to evoke images across language barriers, too.
The leap to music being the "only truth" - we don't all agree on music. Math forces you to agree with it; music does not. By design music has a subjective element to it - emotion. So how can music be "truth?" (edit, again, different songs evoke different emotions in different people - how can this be "truth" - and even if you argue it is "truth to each individual," how is that emotional hiccups are being defined as "truth" here - feeling annoyed by Supertramp whining "Dreeeeamer..." is not truth to me! It's me wondering why I have the damn classic rock station on again - and why are they playing the same damn thirty songs over and over!)
Further, how is it that music will outlast humanity? Without us, music is just a stupid pattern of vibrations. In the "theater of the human mind," THAT is where music "transcends" - where music becomes electrifying, startling, deeply sad, longing, tearful, overwhelming, evoking love - whatever. Music quite arguably will not outlast us because it is so intrinsically linked to us!
Anyway, I find the above quote has more in common with "Twas brillig and the slithy toves" - words that sound important and seem to mean something - but do they really? Well, of course they do or can, if one is "generous" or "nice" about them.
But this is the hunter forum! Sorry!
Edited, Oct 16th 2007 2:05pm by IponemaGirl