What level are you? If your 70, you need to have 490 defense. It takes 2.37
Defense rating to get one point of Defense.
The reason you need 490 is because every mob of equal level will always have a 5% crit rate. I really shouldn't say level. Every mob with a weapon skill equal to your base defense rating has a 5% crit rate.
70 prot pally will have 350 defense skill. All 70 mobs have a 350 weapon skill.
You need 125 defense to lower that 5% to 0%. Now for bosses (70+) you need 5 additional points for each level to catch up to their weapon skill. That makes the magic number 350 + 15 + 125= 490. At 490, you can say good bye to crits.
--------------------------------------------------------
Now just because you cant be crit, doesn't mean you can hit with a
Crushing Blow. To dodge those you have to have 102.4% total avoidance. That will push them off the
Attack Table.
If you can read and understand the links I posted, you'll be fine.
**one quick note on how to figure your Avoidance
You get some freebies. You have a 5% miss rate (mobs towards you). When you mouse over your Defense, it will tell you how much it raises your %s. Add that to the 5% base miss, than add up all your Dodge, Parry, and Block. Thats your total avoidance.