Forum Settings
       
1 2 Next »
Reply To Thread

UA / Felguard talent comparisonFollow

#27 Sep 27 2007 at 2:13 AM Rating: Decent
***
1,571 posts
I have everything hotkeyed, from attack/follow, def or passive to cleave, taunt and intercept and I use it accordingly, specially when I group.
But sometimes when I just want to farm without being much bothered I simply leave him on def with all specials on and I never have mana problems.

2/3 Mana Feed, 3/3 Demonic resilience, 2/2 Imp Health Funnel..... his 6k hp and almost 9k armor - I find him perfectly capable of taking some beating, actually more than I can myself. If I send him on trash elites without any healing and some help with dots he will die of course, but who wouldnt really?

#28 Sep 27 2007 at 7:51 AM Rating: Default
I used a 70 Demo Lock for a few good hours at friends house. That is when all you Demo guys say it "really shines" right? Actually when I let him play my lock afterwards he switched to Affliction as well. I seem to have this effect on people.

TBH I see no point in having a discussion with people who would use VW if they didn't have a Felguard. It's not that they're dumb or don't understand the game... they just simply WANT to rely on a pet. Fine by me, I don't want to, nor did I ever need to. The bulk of my message was intended for pcote, since he asked the question and I feel where he's coming from.
#29 Sep 27 2007 at 1:17 PM Rating: Decent
This whole argument borders on the absu... okay, wait - I don't mean that.

But look, both specs "work." The game's about having fun.

Maybe affliction is a little faster, but if you HATE pure affliction (like I do), you will NOT LEVEL FASTER (because you hate playing affliction and you won't play as much).

There is nothing wrong with liking a good pet and going Felg. It works. You have to "get" how to do it, but once you do, you can really shine. And it works way, WAY better when you can't raid and are a very casual player like me. Are you stuck in greens? Consider learning how to play Felg.

Affliction has enormous advantages. Demon does, too. And a smart Demonlock can beat an Affliction lock, although banish is nastier towards the Demonlock.

If you judge how to play the game based on what a majority seems to be saying is "uber," there's something wrong with you. Who do you vote for - the best candidate for you, or the most popular one? Don't be intimidated. Dig around. Experiment.

Try different builds on the PTR (I did, I found I really hated Destro - I found I liked Affliction better (it does have many strengths and virtues - wow, what a contradiction to say anything regarding warlocks has "virtues" hehehehehe). But I still like my Felgaurd. Call me a felnub, I don't care (btw I know how to play my Felg).

Yes, if you go Felg, you are going to have the elite snobs of Affliction (not all are this way - just look above, you can see which people are) breathing down your neck. But you're a warlock. If you can't handle that, go play Hello Kitty the MMO. In other words "Don't waste my time, mortal" (or whatever his annoying voice emote is). GL and HAVE FUN.

Edited, Sep 27th 2007 5:18pm by IponemaGirl
#30 Sep 27 2007 at 11:18 PM Rating: Decent
***
1,571 posts
IponemaGirl wrote:

If you judge how to play the game based on what a majority seems to be saying is "uber," there's something wrong with you. Who do you vote for - the best candidate for you, or the most popular one? Don't be intimidated. Dig around. Experiment.


It takes unbiased female mind to come to such conclusion.... /bow

Quote:
TBH I see no point in having a discussion with people who would use VW if they didn't have a Felguard. It's not that they're dumb or don't understand the game... they just simply WANT to rely on a pet. Fine by me, I don't want to, nor did I ever need to.


Oh I see - big undependable male that despise relying on someone arent you?
I guess you never rely on your parents or coworkers, you probably hate the idea of having well trained dog to protect your home yard.
Its not that you are dumb or do not understand but life will teach you that relying on someone or something even in some game can be the only way to survive.
And you will definitely need to at some point, trust me on that.


#31 Sep 28 2007 at 4:03 AM Rating: Decent
**
309 posts
Jenovaomega wrote:
my 'arrogance' exists because I have tried it all, I have looked at everything and I've come to the conclusions about it all, you may not like it but I am right (now that is my arrogance unleashed, everything prior was it leashed)


But of course you have, dear. IMO, using the term felnub says more about you than the spec.

As for how the Felguard supposedly sucks before you get demonic frenzy, I'm gonna have to go ahead and giggle at that. He's the only one of our demons that's not useless at the get go. A friend of mine, who plays holy priest, and I went into BRD at lvl 51 (or if it was 52) to farm for kentic amice with just the two of us and my Felguard. It worked because we played together and I manually applied taunts to multiple targets to manage aggro (without a threat meter btw), whilst at the same time killing the mobs and catching runners with CoR. Now there's multi tasking for you.

I'm currently using an affliction spec of 43/8/10, providing imp. imp for our tanks and malediction boosted CoS for the raid. We're going to recruit a new warlock that will get to take over those tasks and that'll give me a chance to start trying out the guard. I plan on getting two parts of t5 and the void star talisman first though (and since I haven't gotten any drop yet, I've got DKP to buy them).

And in case someone would like to question how serious my guild is to let me spec felguard (naturally I'll have to keep up my dps and do my part, and if I feel the spec lacking then I'll spec back!), let me tell you about it.
The guild I'm in is only three weeks old and our raid progress this far is:
Kara: cleared
Gruul: cleared
Maghteridon: cleared
TK: Void reaver down.
SSC: Only Lady Vashj remaining and we're starting on her this sunday.

This weeks raiding after reset:
Wednesday: Gruul, Magtheridon & void reaver. We got delayed and started late so we had to leave it there. Afterwards, nine of us did a casual kara run.
Thursday: Hydross, Lurker, Morogrim, Karathress & Leotheras.
Friday and Saturday: no raids.
Sunday: We're starting on Lady Vashj.
Monday & tuesday: I hope we've downed Vashj by then so on to TK.

When we started we had some pre raiding epics and kara drops (and if you look at my profile you'll see that my gloves and belt are pathetic, curator and illhoof has refused to drop new ones for me ^^). We're not a t5/t6 decked out guild that's steamrolling raidbosses under our gearlvl and calling it progress.
#32 Sep 28 2007 at 5:41 AM Rating: Decent
***
2,754 posts
who ever said it sucked before getting demonic frenzy? for starters in pvp the damage increase due to it isn't much more than 100-200 damage and all the good players use the felnub for 3 completely different reasons anyways.
1. soul-link
2. master demo
3. his intercept stun being the longest lasting stun available to us

oh and pompa. i HAVE tried it all, there isn't a single viable warlock spec i haven't played and tested to a good degree, I thought you lot had learnt that arguing against the big daddy warlock was usless as he always ends up proving you all wrong

:P
#33 Sep 28 2007 at 5:46 AM Rating: Decent
**
309 posts
Jenovaomega wrote:
...i HAVE tried it all...


After looking at your armory profile and your guilds progress at wowjutsu, I'm gonna go ahead and say "Uhm...NO, you haven't!"

EDIT: Do you mean to tell me that you haven't read a single forum post claiming that the fel guard sucks until you get demonic frenzy?

Edited, Sep 28th 2007 3:50pm by pompa
#34 Sep 28 2007 at 8:12 AM Rating: Decent
***
2,754 posts
if you're not including 5mans or raiding then yeah I've never read a post about that and seeing as this post is all about getting felguard basically at the first moment you can then I'd have to say that demonic frenzy wouldn't be to much of a worry, especially once you take into account low low the felnubs att power would be at that level (and tbh how low it is until you hit 70 and get decent +damage)
and the "i have tried it all" is in referance to everything warlock related, yes I've never been to hyal or BT but that's not specifically warlock related :P as I've said I've tried all specs, heck if you include PTRs I've tried all the gear


POST EDIT
I'm actually unguilded right now just to let you know. "the dominion" is/was just a name tag basically. I joined it 'cos a few mates asked me just 'cos they didn't like seeing me without a guild tag. when it comes to guilds I'm applying to try checking out "touch me", "stature of the gods", "defenders of valor", "the gnometrotters", "midnight reveries".


Edited, Sep 28th 2007 12:14pm by Jenovaomega
#35 Sep 28 2007 at 10:01 AM Rating: Decent
***
1,571 posts
Jenovaomega wrote:
the big daddy warlock


O.o

#36 Sep 28 2007 at 11:30 AM Rating: Decent
Sethy wrote:
Oh I see - big undependable male that despise relying on someone arent you?
I guess you never rely on your parents or coworkers, you probably hate the idea of having well trained dog to protect your home yard.
Its not that you are dumb or do not understand but life will teach you that relying on someone or something even in some game can be the only way to survive.
And you will definitely need to at some point, trust me on that.



What?!?!

First to knock you down a peg, I believe you mean independant (undependable would imply that I am not relyable.)

Not to get philosophical but actually your 'sarcastic' quote is VERY VERY true. If you practice statistics or math at all, you'll know that the least degree of error occurs with the fewest amount of variables and the fewest reliant inputs are equated.

To be frank. Sometimes you do have to rely on others. As a general rule, the more you rely on others the more you will be let down (the bigger the degree of error).

I am a male (good call) and I don't rely on my parents, co-workers (in fact I just had a talk to my boss about working alone more often), guidance couselors, psycologists, or anyone else I don't care to trust for no reason. A lot less ridiculously instable inputs in my life is more stability for me.

While on some level you can definatly relate this to my playstyle, the real jist of it is that I play by numbers, and relying on a pet just isn't numerically sound. Just to go back a bit, too...

Sethy wrote:
8 is my personal record and I went OOM before he did.

If you ran out of Mana before you're Fel you're playing incorrectly. Your spec is not designed to fight this many monsters and so your pull was either experimental or accidental - either case it is not efficient. This is contrary to Affliction which thrives on killing at least 3 monsters at a time with a tactic that makes the enemies attack power irrelivant.

My Fliction has grinded through parts where 6 monsters were engaged at any given tiem over the course of approximatedly 12 minutes (about 70 monsters killed w/o break never becoming unengaged in battle). See how long you can do that with a Felguard.

In the end, ya'll are fighting with me a battle I never meant to engage in. If you like using your pet then go Demonology -- it's blatantly obvious and simple. My point to Pcote was initially that he said he DID NOT FEEL COMFORTABLE with the move (being pet dependant) but thought it might be a better or the only route. It isn't. That was my only point throughout this Message board.

BTW I'm sick of people bashing Fliction when they don't even know how to play it, and then calling me out on not playing enough Demo. I know how to play Demo, and even though you can say Fliction is "ez mode" I assure you that if you play Fliction right you will never stop hitting your hotbuttons if you are seriously into your grind, the same cannot be said about Demo (and yes I had a pro demo player show me how he played right infront of me...)

They are different and excell at different things... both can make it to 70. Get over it.


Side note.

IponemaGirl wrote:
And a smart Demonlock can beat an Affliction lock, although banish is nastier towards the Demonlock.


This sounds like you've never played both sides of the fence. It doesn't take a smart Demo to kill a Fliction, it doesn't even take a good one. Demo specializes in 1v1 and there is VERY low chances a Fliction lock will kill a Demo before he will be killed (maybe after, who knows.) Banish doesn't work well against an equal level Demo lock because of the Master Demonolgist skill in addition to the Felguard's naturally high resistances.
#37 Sep 28 2007 at 3:53 PM Rating: Decent
***
2,754 posts
good post tz, only thing i need to correct though is the use of banish vs a felguard. it doesn't actually have naturally high resistance. it has about 45-50 resistance due to master demo and the bonus from our own resistance due to master demo (gotta love that. pet increases our resistance/spell damage which then leads to us increasing their more again ^^) though if a full demo lock goes up against another lock and doesn't fel domination switch to a felhound then they could still happily loose. with the felhound out it's almost impossible to banish the pet and mixing 70 +resistance with soul-link means that we take very little damage from dots (mix resiliance into that too and it becomes even less)
#38 Sep 28 2007 at 5:08 PM Rating: Decent
***
1,571 posts
tzsjynx wrote:

First to knock you down a peg, I believe you mean independant (undependable would imply that I am not relyable.)


You may knock me down on anything you want, English is my second language (maybe even third) so I may be entitled to make some mistakes sometimes.


Quote:
BTW I'm sick of people bashing Fliction when they don't even know how to play it, and then calling me out on not playing enough Demo. I know how to play Demo, and even though you can say Fliction is "ez mode" I assure you that if you play Fliction right you will never stop hitting your hotbuttons if you are seriously into your grind, the same cannot be said about Demo (and yes I had a pro demo player show me how he played right infront of me...)


I am just as well sick of people bashing demo you know - and its mostly affliction people that think they are something better than others for some reason.

I never meant to trash any spec, they all seemed equally viable to me but I got extremely annoyed by "felnubs" and other examples of dissing demo locks at every corner.

I saw affliction locks play by my side and they performed poorly compared - therefore I dont see reason for them to go all haughty and look down at other specs.
If your knowledge about playing demo comes from one person showing it to you then I wouldnt say you have very high knowledge.
I played affliction for 64 levels and for me it was easy and extremely boring. Besides I was never very fast leveler and I tend to respec every few days just to try if one talent point can suit me better at some other place.

What you wrote about relying on pet is simply not true, I rely on my pet just as my pet relies on me, I can trust my pet more than I can trust the people I play with usually. For me its sort of equal relationship and not a flaw on my side.
Being independent (right word now?) is very nice but sometimes it takes more courage to trust someone than to do it all alone.
#39 Sep 28 2007 at 8:21 PM Rating: Decent
***
2,754 posts
sethy. that's not what he means with "rely on pet". what he means is that your ability to win in pvp / do well in pve is dependant on having the right pet out for that occasion and that if your pet happens to die you then become alot more vunrable than most other warlock specs. basically for warlocks our biggest strength is that we have pets but as demo it's also our biggest weakness due to how reliant we become on them.
#40 Sep 28 2007 at 8:31 PM Rating: Default
Sethy wrote:
Being independent (right word now?) is very nice but sometimes it takes more courage to trust someone than to do it all alone.


Very true... Fresh outa Courage when I play my Lock =P


I never used the term Felnub. For all intents and purposes a sh*tty Warlock can play either and still play it badly.

The extent of my actual Playing a lock is limited to about 3 hours with some random guidance from a friend -- true -- but my experience of grouping with, hanging out with, talking to other Locks is very extensive - as I'm sure yours is too.


On a totally side note, while Affliction can come off boring to play, it is the one Tree that really gives back what you put into it. If you do the work you litterally have endless mana, very unique techs, and some interesting strategies for Grinding.

For a long while I followed the Quest route, up till about 40. I learned, though, that while quests were nice for Lock, they could actually pull out much more Exp and G per hour (depending on what they're fighting.)

In my 40s I finished up Desolace Centaurs keeping about 2 going at any given time and moved into Feralas fighting the Yettis at about 4 at a time (i believe it was Yettis) because they dropped Cloth AND could be skinned (was skinner then for cash.) From there moved to Edges of Tanaris where I again took about 3 or 4 at a time and moved into UnGoro. Here's where It got even more fun. Hunting Dactyls and other Dinos I had chains consisting of 7 or 8 CONTINUOUSLY ENGAGED monsters going at one time.

*Edit* I didn't loot much in UnGoro, was too fun just killing =P *Edit*

I cannot tell you how fast I leveled through Ungoro but I will assure you it was quite insane. The sheer repetativeness of it was terrible, yes, but what I was accomplishing was simply staggering.

From then on It got packed down a bit to 2 or 3 until mid 60s and has remained at about a constant 4 or 5 on equal level monsters for grind purposes.

When I say 3 at a time, I don't mean Do 3, rest, do 3, rest. I mean get 1, get another, get another, get another, first dies, get another, second dies, get another, third dies, ect.

For me, this chaining was insanely FUN! It was a delicate balancing act but once you got the hang of it it was definatly doable and very exciting. Yes it was reliable, but it was also dangerous and I'd constantly be having to pop up with certain techs or use my Trinkets or IHoTs unexpectedly. It didn't matter, if I was fighting someone I'd actually getting mana and hp more efficiently than if I was resting. It was an experience that I don't think any other class could share, and it saddens me to hear you thought Fliction was boring.

I will say though that everyone has a different playstyle and as I have litterally said in every post here, if you dont play what you like there's no reason to be playing at all.

Edited, Sep 29th 2007 12:33am by tzsjynx

Edited, Sep 29th 2007 12:41am by tzsjynx
#41 Sep 28 2007 at 9:11 PM Rating: Decent
this may sound stupid, but I gave up drain tanking because I really get annoyed by the sounds the female blood elf makes when taking damage. I get tired of her screams. sometimes I just wish she would die already :).

I don't care if people consider it a more noobish build. I want to play the game how I like it. And not that I roleplay much, but I think it fits in with my character. To have others do her dirty work, not to do it herself.

And it's a huge relief not having to hear her annoying scream anymore. And I was getting so frustrated at losing channeling time. With the talents it's only 70% chance of not losing time, 70% isn't much. Seems like in the 50's I was losing time every single cast. It was really pissing me off. And yes I know the best way is to dot then fear, dot then fear and grind multiple mobs. But you are still supposed to drain one mob with that playstyle right?

bah, I'll get a demon to do my dirty work.
#42 Sep 28 2007 at 11:18 PM Rating: Decent
***
1,571 posts
tzsjynx wrote:

I will say though that everyone has a different playstyle and as I have litterally said in every post here, if you dont play what you like there's no reason to be playing at all.


That is something I very much agree with you.

I do get annoyed with - "if you dont play the way I say because I have so much time played/have been raiding for months/am in "progressing" guild/consider myself daddy warlock (yes Jenova pun intended :p)... then you suck to the point I have right to call you nub, tell you l2p and insult you any way I want".
Such attitude is unacceptable. Period.

I dont have problem asking and taking advices. I never give any advices from the know-it-all point either. I simply like to have my coffee reading something useful and fun and maybe writing an opinion or two from my point of view.
And to be honest, entire WoW I consider only a game I play for relaxation, just the way I want and the way it suits me. I dont care one bit about "general public opinions" and I like to try everything myself before I state something.

I like demo. I might spec something else some day if I am still around and feel like it, but until then I really get offended when some people here start spitting on demo locks just because... to make themselves look better in their own eyes I suppose.
Not saying you are the one of those but the "relying on pet" point is usually what they look down on mostly.
And trust me I know exactly what to rely on someone (or not) means. I am the kind of woman that drove herself 50 km to the hospital in labor pains because I didnt trust my (ex) husband to drive safely at that moment /shrug

#43 Sep 29 2007 at 6:59 AM Rating: Decent
***
2,754 posts
hey I don't call people nubs 'cos they don't play the way I do but if I see someone doing something wrong I do feel it's my duty to help them, now in wow it's easy. i ask, they say yes or no and then the convo ends there but on here I can't exactly ask if they want the info or not so I'll give it and see where things go from there. you are all my children as I am the daddy lock :P
#44 Sep 29 2007 at 7:51 AM Rating: Decent
Excuuuuse me. I am a *******. Ergo, you are not my daddy.

And just to prove I am a *******. You, sir, are now and forever my *****. :oP

;o)
#45 Sep 29 2007 at 8:35 AM Rating: Decent
***
1,571 posts
Oh cammon Jenova, dont overdo it, I could probably be your Mom irl :p

#46 Sep 29 2007 at 8:56 AM Rating: Default
***
2,754 posts
well i hope you're not sethy 'cos that'd make you dutch and incredably angry... so yeah actually you have 1/2 :P and i'm happy to be your ***** ino but only if you agree to be my inu :P
1 2 Next »
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 97 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (97)