DW Fury will always do more Sustained damage in PvE
IF...you have the gear for it.
It is much easier to overcome the miss rate with 2H then it is with DW. Unless you specifically know what you are doing and what gear to take, it is difficult to get yourself enough +hit to not gimp yourself with DW. This is especially hard at lower levels when the itemization is just not there. If you do want to go DW Fury, then what I reccomend is to get 5/5 Cruelty right away and then go down the Arms tree to Impale, while using 2H weapons to level. Once you are at the Impale point, you will start to see better itemization for DW Fury and can start to work down the Fury tree till you get to DW Specialization and that coupled with +hit gear starting to pop up, will make Fury lots less painful to level. There's nothing quite like missing 4 hits in a row.
This is just my opinion and you can do whatever you like. That being said, the miss rate for DW Fury on same leve or 1-2 level higher mobs can be abhorrent without any +hit gear.
Quote:
You are fooling yourselves if you think you can dismiss threat as some ancillery factor. (when tanking)
Agreed. Rate up for that statement. You can't dismiss threat as an ancillery factor even when not tanking, lest you find yourself randomly tanking something you don't want to.
Quote:
All that did was prove that it wasn't the warrior's fault. (they wiped three times with him too, and he was a guildie of one of the guys in the group. He kept praising him and saying they should invite him and get rid of me) Oh well, they finally beat him after 7 attempts or so and had major repair bills. $h!t happens. You live and learn. So, WTF Ever your defiance Bullcrap. I get invites all the time to run instances
Agreed and disagreed. You're right, this probably wasn't the Warriors fault, was probably not a good group, HOWEVER, what you aren't mentioning in your whole statement was the reason for the constant wiping. If it was because the boss kept turning to other people and killing them, then yes indeed, it was your fault. Defiance would have helped you a ton on this. Know why? 15% free threat. FREE. You don't have to do anything special. For as much as you were probably missing the mob and having your attacks dodged, 15% extra threat on everything you did land probably would have helped. Don't be so dismissive.
Quote:
Im not full prot. Im only 15 points in protection. Just suggesting that 3 points in defiance helps dramatically and shouldnt be overlooked.
Definantly. If you are at all going a hybrid build to help your tanking (and no it doesn't gimp your DPS that much) Defiance is a must simply because it makes your job easier. I'm lazy and I'm all for easy.