Forum Settings
       
Reply To Thread

warrior leveling build 1-70Follow

#52 Mar 06 2007 at 7:59 PM Rating: Good
Smiley: king
#53 Mar 06 2007 at 10:09 PM Rating: Good
*
221 posts
Just sticky this already?


hehe
#54 Mar 07 2007 at 2:32 PM Rating: Decent
***
1,395 posts
sjwine wrote:
In my experience you are wrong.

Ime he's right. Tanking is 60% skill. If the healer pulls aggro off you either he's not doing his job right (meaning he overheals, he heals ppl with full health bars) or you're not doing your job right (meaning you're not tanking good).

For heroic 5 mans the story is different, however. Because there you really do need to be prot. Sad But True.
#55 Mar 10 2007 at 2:55 PM Rating: Decent
very well done (im just grabbing this in my list of posts so i can use it later)
#56 Mar 11 2007 at 12:07 PM Rating: Decent
****
4,297 posts
ty. been focusing on attunement instead of alts lately, so my fury warr is still 42. after i get my epic flying mount i'd like to blow a lot of gold going back and forth between arms and fury... maybe...

overheals cause no aggro above the actual hp gain, except from rabid min/maxer raid leaders. and stats fetishists, who lament that heal crits make them look less efficient due to the overheal stat.

i really don't think defiance is required to tank the lowbie stuff (65 and under.) regarding keeping aggro... man try a 6 mob pull with a holy priest, shadow priest, warlock, and hunter. it was maddening at first, but halfway through i joined in and started blowing my fear too, just for kicks lol.

tanking in pugs is less about defiance and fighting to hold *all* the aggro, and more about trusting and learning your party's playstyles, imo. maybe as you're focusing on holding all 5 mobs, the mage or hunter is watching your health bar, and the healer's mana bar, and decides he better pull one of those mobs out of there and kite it around a bit.
#57 Mar 11 2007 at 12:24 PM Rating: Decent
Defiance is not required to tank at all and yes up to my pint (lvl 41) on my warrior i can tank perfectly using whatever i want but sword and shield makes the group go a lot faster because u use less of the healers mana
#58 Mar 12 2007 at 10:48 AM Rating: Decent
what kind of warrior would this make u if followed the guide.
#59 Mar 16 2007 at 8:08 PM Rating: Decent
/bumping cause it belongs up front.

For Axhed:

Great work on this. Just curious what your impression is so far on leveling with DW/Fury vice 2H Arms?
#60 Mar 18 2007 at 11:39 AM Rating: Default
I'm mainly arms, with a couple talents in the Fury tree (will be at DeathWish at 70) and I do just fine holding aggro in instances. at lvl 66 when I ran Sethekk Halls, I did just fine for the most part. Your group just has to let you get some sunders off and TC's and stuff before they go in there DPS'n the crap outta the mob. So I don't think i'll ever throw a point into the prot. tree, only for the simple fact that I will/might run some more instances for the xp and rep and then i'll just PvP to get the gear I want (thats why i rolled a pvp server)

I'm just tired of the same ole "Warriors are tanks, if you don't like it, re-roll another class" bull/$h!t. I love PvP'ing on a PvP server. I still get the job done in a 5 man and haven't had any complaints yet, except the Sethekk Halls one, but they were all 68,69, and 70, and didnt like the fact that i was 66 and not a prot. warrior with defense of like 330. lol Well they decided to boot me after the 2nd or 3rd wipe of the last boss, and got a 70 warrior. All that did was prove that it wasn't the warrior's fault. (they wiped three times with him too, and he was a guildie of one of the guys in the group. He kept praising him and saying they should invite him and get rid of me) Oh well, they finally beat him after 7 attempts or so and had major repair bills. $h!t happens. You live and learn. So, WTF Ever your defiance Bullcrap. I get invites all the time to run instances

/hotcarl
#61 Mar 18 2007 at 3:56 PM Rating: Decent
****
4,297 posts
PigeonMan wrote:
So, WTF Ever your defiance Bullcrap.


chisox manager whose name escapes me at the moment wrote:
pshhht. please.


initial impressions of leveling dw fury post level 40: if you've got the gold to spend on consumables and weapons and are willing to do so, it's great. if not, meh.

it certainly feels faster, because you can button mash heroics and convince yourself you're playing good... but with average gear (but a good slow 2H) and methodical execution i still think arms does more damage.

adding +dmg chants, sharpening stones, and gift of arthas pots tips the scales heavily towards dw fury.

Edited, Mar 18th 2007 8:14pm by axhed
#62 Mar 18 2007 at 7:19 PM Rating: Good
*
80 posts
Quote:
I'm just tired of the same ole "Warriors are tanks, if you don't like it, re-roll another class" bull/$h!t. I love PvP'ing on a PvP server. I still get the job done in a 5 man and haven't had any complaints yet, except the Sethekk Halls one, but they were all 68,69, and 70, and didnt like the fact that i was 66 and not a prot. warrior with defense of like 330. lol Well they decided to boot me after the 2nd or 3rd wipe of the last boss, and got a 70 warrior. All that did was prove that it wasn't the warrior's fault. (they wiped three times with him too, and he was a guildie of one of the guys in the group. He kept praising him and saying they should invite him and get rid of me) Oh well, they finally beat him after 7 attempts or so and had major repair bills. $h!t happens. You live and learn. So, WTF Ever your defiance Bullcrap. I get invites all the time to run instances


Im sorry, but I'm going to have to keep on disagreeing.

You need to be the primary threat producer and you have to compete against healers, mages,rogues, locks in particular those who are highter levelled or better geared then you.

You are fooling yourselves if you think you can dismiss threat as some ancillery factor. (when tanking)

Your example of what happened to you in Setthek halls is really exactly my point. Your replacement warrior who was 70 that also botched it up 3 times probably also didnt have points in defiance.

#63 Mar 19 2007 at 3:17 AM Rating: Decent
I am willing to admit that I was relatively low for the instance condsidering the elites were 3-4 lvl's higher than I was. I don't think "defiance" would have been a saving grace either way, but hey, we're all entitled to our own opinions. And thats exactly what they are. There really insn't anything to debate since we're not in debate class. You can have your defiance and be a true "tank" and I will sac the prot tree and go the road of PvP.
#64 Mar 19 2007 at 8:13 AM Rating: Decent
***
1,395 posts
@ sjwine: Look... I've tanked every instance I've been in so far in TBC and I'm lvling specced. As for taking on a boss 4 lvls higher than you... I wouldn't. It a waste of everybody's time. I tank instances MY lvl and I think I do it great. I consider myself being a fairly skilled tank, without sounding obnoxious or anything.

I have NEVER went full prot in my whole life, and I havn't needed it either.

I really don't care what your arguments are (don't take this the wrong way... I'm not flaming you, just disagreing somewhat hotly). I think it's a general opinion that the only thing you NEED for tanking is skill. Doesn't matter what gear you have or if you have every talent point you own in the prot tree... If you don't have skill you're phucked.

In summary: For tanking: SKILLZ > EVERYTHING ELSE!!!
#65 Mar 19 2007 at 2:46 PM Rating: Decent
*
80 posts
Im not full prot. Im only 15 points in protection. Just suggesting that 3 points in defiance helps dramatically and shouldnt be overlooked.
#66 Mar 21 2007 at 12:44 AM Rating: Decent
***
1,395 posts
Oh sorry. I got the impression you were implying that you needed points in prot to tank, rather than just saying it helps.
#67 Mar 21 2007 at 1:06 AM Rating: Decent
**
354 posts
DW Fury will always do more Sustained damage in PvE


IF...you have the gear for it.

It is much easier to overcome the miss rate with 2H then it is with DW. Unless you specifically know what you are doing and what gear to take, it is difficult to get yourself enough +hit to not gimp yourself with DW. This is especially hard at lower levels when the itemization is just not there. If you do want to go DW Fury, then what I reccomend is to get 5/5 Cruelty right away and then go down the Arms tree to Impale, while using 2H weapons to level. Once you are at the Impale point, you will start to see better itemization for DW Fury and can start to work down the Fury tree till you get to DW Specialization and that coupled with +hit gear starting to pop up, will make Fury lots less painful to level. There's nothing quite like missing 4 hits in a row.

This is just my opinion and you can do whatever you like. That being said, the miss rate for DW Fury on same leve or 1-2 level higher mobs can be abhorrent without any +hit gear.

Quote:
You are fooling yourselves if you think you can dismiss threat as some ancillery factor. (when tanking)

Agreed. Rate up for that statement. You can't dismiss threat as an ancillery factor even when not tanking, lest you find yourself randomly tanking something you don't want to.

Quote:
All that did was prove that it wasn't the warrior's fault. (they wiped three times with him too, and he was a guildie of one of the guys in the group. He kept praising him and saying they should invite him and get rid of me) Oh well, they finally beat him after 7 attempts or so and had major repair bills. $h!t happens. You live and learn. So, WTF Ever your defiance Bullcrap. I get invites all the time to run instances

Agreed and disagreed. You're right, this probably wasn't the Warriors fault, was probably not a good group, HOWEVER, what you aren't mentioning in your whole statement was the reason for the constant wiping. If it was because the boss kept turning to other people and killing them, then yes indeed, it was your fault. Defiance would have helped you a ton on this. Know why? 15% free threat. FREE. You don't have to do anything special. For as much as you were probably missing the mob and having your attacks dodged, 15% extra threat on everything you did land probably would have helped. Don't be so dismissive.

Quote:
Im not full prot. Im only 15 points in protection. Just suggesting that 3 points in defiance helps dramatically and shouldnt be overlooked.

Definantly. If you are at all going a hybrid build to help your tanking (and no it doesn't gimp your DPS that much) Defiance is a must simply because it makes your job easier. I'm lazy and I'm all for easy.
#68 Mar 22 2007 at 7:14 PM Rating: Default
Omg stickey this already someone!!!!

Questio: Does imp Revenge work on bosses or only normal mobs?
#69 Mar 22 2007 at 8:27 PM Rating: Decent
**
354 posts
The number of bosses that can be stunned I can probably count on 1 hand. Same with Raid Mobs, as you start to progress further in content, the fewer mobs can be stunned.
#70 Mar 29 2007 at 8:57 AM Rating: Decent
**
924 posts
Dude.. I'm loving this guide. There's a lot of either outdated or ZOMG-SPEC-NOW-OR-U-DIEZ!!1 threads on the o-boards, and.. when I start seeing "Take this or you aren't a real warrior" threads about talents that no longer exist, I'm pretty sure all hope's lost. That'll teach me for entering the o-boards, eh?

But.. yeah. I'm still really in the dark with warriors. I'm mostly a rogue and warlock guy, the whole dps thing's usually my cup of tea. I'm having fun on my warrior at the moment.. not a big fan of the pennies-in-the-pocket sound that they make in mail. That I can live with.. but the rest of it?

Some stuff I get, arms actually makes a fair bit of sense to me. The tooltips aren't hard to wrap your brain around. But I hear so many people zomging about fury (DW as much as two hand). Is the increased rage generation really worth giving up the burst damage, crit and utility? : \



..this **** needs a stickie. I wish I remembered how to get an application for one..

Edited, Mar 29th 2007 10:59am by Banatu
#71 Apr 03 2007 at 4:48 PM Rating: Decent
shameless bump
#72 Apr 04 2007 at 11:51 AM Rating: Decent
Quote:
but seemed to have less "Oh crap" options. Maybe it was because I was lower level, don't know, but with my Arm's build now unless I get more than 3 mobs I just sigh because I'll need to use a big bandaid instead of a minor one.


OMGAWD something is not right here! I love the OH CRAP options fury offers...with a high crit rating rampage is almost always up, and if you need to hit a trinket, deathwish, and if desperate, reckelssness and just cleave away or BT stuff and WW..your taking so much dmg that you have enough rage to do whatever you need to, plus with victory rush, for every dead mob there is a free 900(1300 crit) free dmg..in Nagrand in the murkblood village just the other day i was fighting 2 of the more hp mobs when a mage ran by trailing 4 other mobs and they killed him and agrod on me, i took care of them all with the options fury offers.. just as i described in fact, didnt even use a pot ( those dont tend to stay in my inventory long...victory rush tends to keep me floating around half hp.)

Edited, Apr 4th 2007 2:52pm by Romyo
#73 Apr 04 2007 at 1:00 PM Rating: Decent
Am I the only one who finds Impale rather...underwhelming? All it does is take a critical bonus from +100% to +120%. Granted, this can be a decent chunk of damage, but I don't think it'd be my first option...I'd rather fill out 2h spec/poleaxe first, or get Cruelty back.
#74 Apr 04 2007 at 4:56 PM Rating: Decent
Quote:
I'd rather fill out 2h spec/poleaxe first, or get Cruelty back.


Then fill out your 2h, get cruelty, and invest the rest of your points to your own liking. The best part of 'spec' is specialize. Fine tune it to your own play style..I like blowing stuff up personally, so any % increase to dmg i can get, im all over it. ^_^
#75 Apr 05 2007 at 5:09 AM Rating: Decent
Oh, I totally agree; I'm just prodding trying to see what makes everyone think Impale is so awesome. It's great if you need the points to fill out the tree to get to 41, but it's not all that hot in itself, so I was wondering why people seem to take it immediately when it becomes available.
#76 Apr 05 2007 at 8:52 AM Rating: Decent
****
4,297 posts
you get an extra crit's worth of damage out of every 5 crits, plus deep wounds.

i got jumped by a tricked out stunlock rogue awhile back, the only thing i landed was a hamstring crit.

he bled out to about 60% or 70% or something.
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 143 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (143)