Forum Settings
       
Reply To Thread

data on bare knucklesFollow

#1 Mar 13 2005 at 6:14 PM Rating: Decent
People often wonder if using bare knuckles as a brawler is worth it. So have I ^_^
So I tested it out, and here are my results:
(*experiment details follow*)

I compared my bare hands to dual-wielding Splintering Staves and used a parser to try to figure out the damage/delay of bare hands.

My weapons:
2 x Splintering Staff del: 1.8 dam: 6-18 ("my current" damage)
+4AGI +4STR

Char/stats: lvl 19 Brawler (unbuffed)
57 Str
59 Agi

Avrg DPS = 11.3

----------------------

With bare hands, my char had 49 Str & 51 Agi

Lowest hit = 16
Highest hit = 46
Avrg Hit = 31
Avrg DPS = 10.1

Therefore,
31/x = 10
x = about 3.1

Therefore bare knuckles on a lvl 19 appear to be something like
del:[/sm] 3.1 dam: 16-46

(comparable to a typical one-handed weapon, but without stat boosts, of course)

------------------------

Conclusion:

While bare knuckles may be comparable up to lvl 19, I believe the significant stat boosts of the staves raised the dps. The +4 agi per weapon was worth it if not for the dps but for the AC (I got chewed up fighting bare-handed). You can, however, put a weapon in the offhand for at least some stats.

Hopefully this will put the questions to rest somewhat:
Q: Are bare hands as strong as weapons?
A: At least up to 19, they aren't shabby.

Q: Should I use my bare hands?
A: I wouldn't.

-------------------------

Experiment data (you can stop reading now unless this stuff fascinates you)

Parser used: CombatStats (duh)
Mob fought: Fallen Lieutenants
Why?: Low-level mobs are easier to hit and present a best-case scenario for weapon statistics. Also, ^^ mobs have more HP which = more data. Lastly, they're easy to find.
Number of Trials: 20 fights (10 with each wpn combo)
Why at lvl 19?: To get data on the highest lvl char I could w/o branching off into sub-class (which is a different set of experiments all together)
What skills did you use?: None, this was done entirely with weapon dps. In fact, bare-handed attacks may actually lead to more dps when combined w/attack skills... still need to try it
---------------------------

Edited, Mon Mar 28 14:37:56 2005 by Follier
#2 Mar 13 2005 at 6:45 PM Rating: Decent
Update:

Just for kicks I fought one fight of each with basic skills to see if there's a significant difference.

Avrg DPS of weapons + skills = 21.4
Avrg DPS of bare hands + skills = 20.1 (but was less consistant on the monitor, making jumps from like 18 to 26 and back)

Skills used: 1) Bruising Strike, 2)[trigger], 3) Focused Strike, 4) Beslin's Posture [HO], repeat 2-4.

It's probably accurate to say then (as others have, and as I've scoffed at) that hard-hitting high-delay weapons actually yield competitive or better DPS while skill-spamming (which us brawlers tend to do). This would go for all classes. It's not conclusive, but I'm a bit more convinced.
#3 Mar 15 2005 at 6:27 AM Rating: Decent
*
138 posts
Good info. I'd be real interested to see what the Fiery Fists buff does to this. If you get a chance please run a test using that barehanded as opposed to using the weapons. Thanks.
#4 Mar 16 2005 at 2:44 PM Rating: Decent
I'll definately do that! While I'm nearly lvl 21, I have to go out of town for awhile. But you'll see some numbers on Fiery Fist next week ^_^

My offhand guess is that it'll boost the numbers in favor of using weapons, since more attacks usually means more damage from procs.

Also, I've found the following things interesting:

1) Equipping a dual-wield weapon in the primary only will cause you to attack only with that weapon.
2) Equipping a d/w weapon in the secondary will allow you to use one fist also.
3) Parsing I was doing w/ a good group in FG last night suggests that using one fist and one weapon yeilds slightly higher DPS than dual-wielding or being totally bare-fisted. << When I became the main tank, however, I switched to dual-wield... the stat boosts can make a huge difference to defense >>

I also learned that a trigger-happy warlock is insane dps... made me and the assassin look like we were fighting with wiffle bats LOL.





Edited, Wed Mar 16 17:28:03 2005 by Follier
#5 Mar 17 2005 at 5:47 AM Rating: Decent
*
138 posts
LoL! No no, my defiler fights with a wiffle bat.

The reason I ask for the fiery fists data is because I'm not sure if the proc works while using weapons. I have pretty much always used dual wield weapons so I don't even know if there is a proc appearence on that buff. I did a little playing around yesterday with grey mobs using weapons and bare fists. Never saw a proc.

Whenever you get to it is great. Thanks for the data you posted above and in advance thanks for the data using Fiery Fists. Have fun outta town.
#6 Mar 28 2005 at 2:34 PM Rating: Decent
Little update, as some folks were kind enough to point out, bare hand is not dual wield, although you can equip a weapon in the secondary if you want for stat boosts (though you wont attack with it).

So I'll edit the post a little :)

As far as Fiery Fists, yes it procs with weapons. It doesn't give a neat little message like Thundering Fists does, you just have to watch for the little non-melee numbers to pop up. As I still only have App 1 or 2 it only procs 3% or the time. It seems to proc even less than that, though I may have just missed it. With both weapons and bare hand it only hits once (maybe twice) a fight for me at lvl 22.
Thundering fists, on the other hand, can proc 5-10 times a fight with its 5%... (but then again, I can count the proc messages).

Since it seems that weapons with lower delay don't proc as often as those with high delay (see the scout posts regarding poisons), I'd guess that the rate is about the same with both.

Also it seems to me that while dam/del bare hands does change as you level (I punched for 61 the other day), my weapon skills' dps passed it up by quite a large margin after I dinged 20 (both with and without skill spamming).

And lastly, in case anyone is dying to know, the haste attached to that specced taunt seems to be insignificant. It barely makes up the dps lost from the casting time to use it. I ran numbers (with both weapons and bare hands) first using the taunt/haste and then not, and I couldn't find any noticable differences in the averages at all.


(fought 10 grey ^^ essenses in Wailing Caves for each set of those numbers)



Edited, Mon Mar 28 14:42:13 2005 by Follier
#7 Mar 29 2005 at 4:29 AM Rating: Decent
*
138 posts
Great info! Thank you very much.
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 108 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (108)