Mistress Nadenu,
This is coming with the perspective of soloing, so if you group, duo or more, it may differ.
With my Guardian I actually do all three fighting styles, sword/board, 2h and duel wield. I only take out the sword/board when I group up (close to full party). I use duel wield mainly when I'm fighting casters. I don't know if this is fact or not for everyone, but I've had better experiences in taking down caster gnolls with duel wield than I do with the 2h. I use a greatsword for pretty much everything else and even sometimes on casters when I'm too lazy to switch weapons (but I do burn a lot more abilities just to kill the caster). hehehe
As far as HP/AC > Damage, yes, Guardians are not offensive. If however, you want to be a damage tank but stick to the warrior line, Berserker is where it's at.
If you're duo'ing with a healer, you could use a 2h instead of sword/board for the added damage.
I miss my Guardian but being sneaky sneaky is fun... Decisions!
Edited, Thu Feb 3 18:33:46 2005 by ArcosKojin