"Does that mean that your guild members are not allowed into the guild lobby or hall, or POK and that if they are found there they are deguilded?"
They would be warned the first time.
"what aa's do you consider not beneficial? Just general or just stat increases or do you not allow your guild members to spend their points so that in that case they just get destroyed above 30?"
By not beneficial, we mean Int casters spending AAs points in Innate Wis.
"And so if you are fighting a lion in east karana or a gnoll in south karana and you loot a rough or crude defiant robe or breastplate you do what? just destroy it on the spot or bank it until your guild decides to allow ppl to wear it? This sounds really really weird and sort of communist mentality."
Defiant is overpowered for what we are doing, and so is hotzone/revamped loot. We are raiding 'classic' encounters. What is the point of raiding them with insane gear for the era, and never needing any loot off them before of that? We feel it defeats the purpose of we are doing, and do not allow it. Vindi was quite a challenge to do with a classic geared tank (Planar armor and epics), and the bp was quite an upgrade for him.
As for the destroying of Defiant armor, you can keep it and put it on some char that isn't in the guild, or sell it and buy gear for a char that isn't it the guild. We don't care what you do with this stuff, as long as it does not affect your guilded character in any way, which means no selling it and using the play on the character.
Sure, these strict rules aren't for everyone, but we enjoy them. There's two other similar guilds on The Combine, with less strict rules: Lords of the Combine and Dawn of Marr (you can search for them on guildportal). They allow hotzone/revamped loot and AAs. Lords of the Combine allow basic AAs, like resists and such, while Dawn of Marr allow all level 60 AAs, along with PoK/Bazaar/Guild Lobby. They are progression and will go past Velious eventually.
Basically, there's a progression/classic guild for everyone. The three guilds on The Combine are in Kunark/Velious, while that guild on the Test server (Unintended Consequences) is in PoP. Just pick whichever one sounds best for you, and I'm sure you'll have a lot of fun.