I have played EQ1 since 2000. I had three accounts (two were given to me by players that quit the game), and three-boxed regularly. Had 5 players 65+, two time flagged, all VT keyed. I loved EQ1. By 2003, I was burned out. I liked the game, but it became a chore. Raids every night, backflagging, DKP gathering, epics, AA farming.... I felt that I needed more and more time to do stuff. Every new expansion meant more time blown to "beat" them. Every rare camp agravated me, every rare drop that I didn't win only meant more time spent to try getting another chance. I stopped playing cold.. no desire to come back.
When EQ2 came out, I gave it a shot. EQ2 was really fun at first. All the stuff I hated about EQ1 were gone. "Rare" spawns only took at most 2 hours to spawn. Everyone can solo. The quest journal was a godsend. No one could KS you, no one could train you, no twinks, no powerlevelling, no farming.
But, unfortunately, the things that made EQ1 agravating are also the things that make it rewarding. Completing things in EQ2 never felt rewarding because there was little risk in achieving them. Sure, some quests took a long time and required some luck, but it was just a matter of time before you could finish anything.
Also, EQ2 took out a lot of things that made the game "realistic". Mobs do not chase you all across the zone. They stay in predefined areas and cannot be pulled past them. Mobs are either in preselected groups, or solo, so you know exactly what you are pulling, but the art of pulling is gone. You can attack a solo-tagged orc hanging around a bunch of other orcs and you will get no adds. Fights are not very creative. There is no real kiting of any kind. Once a mob becomes "gray" (green in EQ1), it cannot touch you - you can have 30 gray mobs whacking you at once and you will barely be harmed at all.
That said, EQ2 has some fantastic features. Some people said that it should be different that EQ1 but I disagree. I wanted EQ2 to be EQ1 with more stuff. It happens to be a new game that makes use of EQ1 names.
Maybe EQ3 will be what I'm looking for.
____________________________
Duke Ardnahoy
Noble Lord Protector of the 70th Crusade
Fennin Ro - EQ I
Ardnahoy II
Fearless Guardian of the 40th Tour
Mistmore - EQ II