Well since a GM hasn't gotten back to me yet (thanks to the new Petition interface that's bugged half the time) I figured I'd ask here and see what the chances are of getting back an item that was destroyed by an NPC.
I was doing the Druid Epic quest and I was at the point where I could turn in the Runecrested Bowl and Hardened Mixture to Ella Foodcrafter in Misty Thicket. I had the instructions next to me to what to do with the two items. So I track her, and I accidently turned in the Hardened Mixture without the runecrested bowl. She did not say anything, just took the item and kept walking. As far as I know, if an NPC turn in does not match what is required they should give back the item correct? My faction with her was fine because she gave me items earlier for my epic. So I decided to petition since I really don't feel like doing the same part of my epic over again (that part is very time consuming since it's all based on luck.) Do you think the GM will return my item? Or will he/she just say something like, "Epics are suppose to be tough! Redo that portion of the epic."
To me, it's a bug in the game, and it logically doesnt make sense that you'd loose an epic piece for making a mistake.