It's a tossup, more or less. It really depends on the prices in the bazaar, and your access to a jeweler with all the maxed out skills and gear.
On my server, the metallic liquids alone sell in the 4k range. Vallorium rings sell in the 9k range. With a chanter with maxed skill, and the +skill stuff (don't ask me what they are), you're gonna have about a 50/50 chance. In my case, I had enough components for 2 ring attempts. Since a member of my guild has all the maxed jewelcraft stuff, I had him make the attempts. I was taking the risk that I'd get two failures against the possiblity that I'd get two successes. In my case, I just got 1 ring. I could just as easily have sold the two metallic liquids, saved the cost of the other components, and just bought a ring with the money I made/didn't spend.
It's a wash really. If you want to guarantee you get a ring, you're probably better off just selling the liquid. If you're up for taking the risk, and you have someone to do the combine, then you can choose that route. Just be advised, if you only have one set of materials, and that combine fails, you've got nothing to show for it. If you'd sold the liquid, you'd be halfway towards getting a ring...
In my case, I didn't care that much. I only really *needed* one ring, so if I'd gotten two it would have just been a bonus.
____________________________
King Nobby wrote:
More words please