Hi,
First off let me apologize for this lengthy post.
Actually during my earlier levels, I did start off by pulling with arrows but the adds were a problem. If I had adds - the target and adds would be on me like a ton of bricks - and with "You are stunned" more often than not, I had a lot of trouble rooting them. I switched to Snare so at least the target was slowed - leaving the adds to be dealt with. Over time the Snare pull just became a habit (a bad one now I realize, but a habit born out of circumstances at the time - mea culpa). I will most definitely pull with arrows now, if there is a CC in the group - or try the Tangling Weeds.
OldBlue - that was a nice summation of the Armors and I agree with you that Gothic looks mighty nice! The AC, STR and MR are reasons enough to go for the Gothic. Just to complicate things, I took your work a little further and compared Ivy Etched too. I used the same basic 5 items you did - Chest, Head, Hands, Legs and Arms. I also added in two additional fields - Weight and the difference between Strength and Weight - all stats from Allakhazam. I got the following -
Ry'Gorr Basic 5 Items - AC +67, STR +15, STA +2, AGI +3, DEX +2, PR +5, Mana +35, CHA +1, HP +20, MR +9, CR +10
Gothic Ringmail Basic 5 Items - AC +67, STR + 12, STA +13, MR +30
Ivy Etched Basic 5 Items - AC +64, STR +7, AGI +5, HP +30, CR +12, FR +12, WIS +8, DR +5
Ok now adding in the Weight and Strength - Weight:
Ry'Gorr Basic - STR +15, Wt +14 ...... STR-Wt = +1
Gothic Basic - STR +12, Wt +16.5 ...... STR-Wt = -4.5
Ivy Basic - STR +7, Wt +20.2 ..... STR-Wt = -13.2
In effect, as I see it the STR factor is negated by weight for Ry'Gorr and gives a penalty to Gothic and a severe penalty to Ivy. The AC for all is similar and reduces the decision to:
Ry'Gorr Basic 5 Items - STA +2, AGI +3, DEX +2, PR +5, Mana +35, CHA +1, HP +20, MR +9, CR +10
Gothic Ringmail Basic 5 Items - STA +13, MR +30
Ivy Etched Basic 5 Items - AGI +5, HP +30, CR +12, FR +12, WIS +8, DR +5
For a complete set of the three Armors - I get the following aggregate stats:
Ry'Gorr Basic 5 + Chain Bracer + Collar + Cloak of the Ry'Gorr Oracles: AC +91, STA +6, AGI +3, DEX +2, PR +3, Mana +45, CHA +3, HP +25, MR +18, CR +20, WIS +2, INT +2 ..... STR +17, Wt +21.5, STR-Wt = -4.5
Gothic Basic 5 + Bracelet + Boots + Gorget + Mantle + Skirt + Cloak + Veil: AC +125, STA + 30, MR +72 ..... STR +26, Wt +34.6, STR-Wt = -8.6
Ivy Basic 5 + Boots + Bracer: AC + 83, STA +5, AGI +5, DEX + 2, PR +3, HP +30, CR + 12, FR +12, WIS +8, DR +5 ..... STR +7, Wt +26.1, STR-Wt = -19.1
Comparing Ry'Gorr full set with equivalent Gothic (8 Items - Chest, Head, Hands, Legs, Arms, Wrist Neck and Cloak):
Ry'Gorr all 8 items: AC +91, STA +6, AGI +3, DEX +2, PR +3, Mana +45, CHA +3, HP +25, MR +18, CR +20, WIS +2, INT +2 ..... STR +17, Wt +21.5, STR-Wt = -4.5
Gothic 8 items: AC +92, STA +20, MR +48 ..... STR +18, Wt +24.7, STR-Wt = -6.7
As far as I understand it, the Strength stat is related to the damage one dishes out. It's ironical that the Ivy is the worst one and is the Ranger quested Armor. I am tending to lean towards the Ry'Gorr because I need fewer items and leaves me with a deficit of STA 14 and MR 30 - as compared to similar Gothic. But I have more slots open (Boots, Face etc) so I can raise those stats by other items and at the same time the Ry'Gorr gives me other stat boosts too. Then again, the best way might be to simply mix and match as Oneprime said.
However, I have a question regarding Stamina. My understanding is that Stamina improves Hit Points, but this improvement is more effective or more noticeable towards the high end of the game. I got this from http://eq.crgaming.com/creationguides/Ranger.asp in the write-up on Stamina. If this is true - then can I bump Stamina further down the list of desirable stats at my level until - say the 40 level or so?
In order of descending importance, I was looking for the following stats in my Armor - AC, STR, MR, AGI, DEX and the rest in no particular order.
BTW - does anyone know of any better/other character creation guides than those at eq.crgaming.com ?
Thanks